Oxalate Nephropathy in Farm Animals

Quick Facts

🏥 Condition Name
Oxalate Nephropathy
📋 Also Known As
Oxalate Nephropathy
📂 Category
Urinary System
📁 Subcategory
N/A
🐄 Affects
Kidneys, renal tubules, and systemic calcium balance
🏷️ Type
Toxic/Nutritional
⚠️ Severity
Moderate to Severe
💊 Treatable
Treatable if detected early and toxic source removed; chronic damage may be irreversible
🔄 Contagious
No
🧬 Hereditary
No
🐄 Common In
Cattle, sheep, and goats exposed to high-oxalate plants; all grazing ruminants

Oxalate Nephropathy Overview

Oxalate nephropathy is a form of kidney disease in farm animals caused by ingestion of plants containing high levels of oxalates or oxalic acid. When animals consume oxalate-containing plants in sufficient quantity, the oxalates are absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract and bind with calcium in the blood, forming insoluble calcium oxalate crystals. These crystals accumulate in the kidneys, particularly within the renal tubules, causing mechanical damage, inflammation, and ultimately functional impairment of the kidneys. The condition can range from mild, subclinical kidney damage to acute, life-threatening kidney failure depending on the amount of oxalate consumed and the duration of exposure.

The condition primarily affects grazing ruminants including cattle, sheep, and goats, as these species are most likely to encounter and consume oxalate-accumulating plants in pasture settings. However, pigs and other livestock may also be affected if fed contaminated feeds or given access to areas where toxic plants grow. The geographic distribution of oxalate nephropathy parallels the distribution of high-oxalate plant species, with certain regions experiencing regular outbreaks due to the prevalence of plants such as halogeton, sorrel, greasewood, and pigweed. Seasonal patterns often correspond to environmental conditions that increase plant oxalate content or decrease availability of safe forages.

The economic and welfare impact of oxalate nephropathy varies from sporadic individual losses to devastating herd-level events when naive animals encounter dense stands of highly toxic plants. Mass mortality events have been documented when range cattle or sheep are moved into areas with heavy halogeton growth, particularly when animals are hungry and consume large quantities quickly. Subclinical kidney damage from chronic low-level oxalate exposure may reduce production efficiency without causing obvious disease. The welfare implications include kidney pain, malaise, and in severe cases the distressing terminal stages of acute kidney failure. Prevention through pasture management and awareness of toxic plants is far preferable to treating established toxicosis.

Treatability of oxalate nephropathy depends on the severity of exposure and how quickly intervention occurs. Animals removed from the oxalate source early, before extensive kidney damage has occurred, often recover completely with supportive care. Those with established acute kidney failure face a more guarded prognosis, though aggressive fluid therapy and supportive care can save some animals. Chronic, repeated exposure leading to cumulative kidney damage may result in permanent renal impairment. Understanding which plants pose oxalate toxicity risk and managing livestock access to these plants represents the most effective approach to minimizing the impact of this condition.

Causes of Oxalate Nephropathy

The primary cause of oxalate nephropathy is ingestion of plants that accumulate high concentrations of oxalic acid and oxalate salts. Numerous plant species across multiple families contain significant oxalate levels, with the most dangerous in North America including halogeton, greasewood, soursob, dock and sorrel species, pigweed and lambsquarters, and rhubarb leaves. These plants may contain three to eight percent or more oxalate on a dry weight basis, with levels varying based on plant maturity, growing conditions, and environmental factors. Drought stress, high nitrogen fertilization, and certain soil conditions can increase plant oxalate content, making plants more dangerous during these periods.

There is no known genetic or breed predisposition to oxalate nephropathy per se, though differences in grazing behavior between breeds may influence the likelihood of consuming dangerous quantities of toxic plants. Animals naive to an area with unfamiliar toxic plants may be more likely to consume them than animals with local experience. Some ruminants develop partial adaptation to oxalate-containing plants through modifications in rumen microbial populations that can degrade some oxalate before absorption, but this adaptation is limited and can be overwhelmed by large doses. Individual variation in rumen flora and function may influence susceptibility to some degree.

Environmental and management factors play crucial roles in oxalate nephropathy occurrence. Overgrazing that depletes palatable forages while leaving toxic plants ungrazed increases the risk that hungry animals will consume dangerous species. Drought conditions both increase plant oxalate content and reduce availability of safe forages, creating a dangerous combination. Moving animals into unfamiliar territory where toxic plants grow, particularly when animals are hungry from transport, has caused numerous mass poisoning events. Allowing animals access to garden waste containing rhubarb leaves or similar materials has caused toxicosis in farm settings.

Risk factors for developing oxalate nephropathy include recent introduction to areas where toxic plants grow, hunger or nutritional stress that encourages consumption of normally avoided plants, lack of previous exposure to allow rumen microflora adaptation, and simultaneous calcium deficiency that reduces the animal's ability to buffer absorbed oxalates. Young animals may be more susceptible than adults due to smaller body size and potentially less diverse rumen microbial populations. Animals with pre-existing kidney disease may be less able to tolerate additional insult from oxalate exposure.

The pathophysiology of oxalate nephropathy involves several mechanisms of injury. Absorbed oxalate binds rapidly with ionized calcium in the blood, potentially causing hypocalcemia with associated neuromuscular effects. The calcium oxalate complexes precipitate as insoluble crystals that accumulate preferentially in the kidneys due to the concentrating mechanisms of urine formation. These crystals mechanically damage renal tubular epithelial cells, obstruct tubular lumens, and incite inflammatory responses. The resulting tubular necrosis impairs kidney function, and if damage is extensive, acute kidney failure develops. Surviving animals may have residual nephron loss and scarring affecting long-term kidney function.

Symptoms & Warning Signs

Early warning signs of oxalate nephropathy may develop within hours of consuming toxic quantities of oxalate-containing plants. Animals may appear uncomfortable, showing mild colic signs with treading, shifting weight, and looking at the flank region. Decreased appetite is common, with affected animals showing disinterest in feed even when group mates are eating. Mild depression and reduced activity levels may be observed. If hypocalcemia is significant, early signs may include muscle tremors or stiffness. Careful observers may note decreased fecal output as gastrointestinal motility slows. These early signs can be subtle and easily attributed to other causes, making high index of suspicion important in areas with known toxic plant exposure.

Common symptoms vary somewhat based on whether the primary presentation is acute hypocalcemia, acute kidney failure, or combined effects. Cattle with oxalate toxicosis often show initial signs of hypocalcemia including muscle weakness, tremors, staggering gait, and sometimes recumbency resembling milk fever. Depression and inappetence are prominent. As kidney failure develops, decreased urine output is noted, though this may be difficult to assess in extensive management systems. Sheep are particularly susceptible to oxalate poisoning and may show rapid progression from initial weakness to recumbency and death, sometimes within twelve to twenty-four hours of consuming toxic quantities of plants like halogeton. Goats show similar susceptibility to sheep, with rapid progression possible after significant exposure.

Behavioral changes in animals with oxalate nephropathy reflect the systemic nature of the toxicosis. Affected animals separate from the flock or herd, showing decreased social interaction and reluctance to move when the group does. Grazing activity ceases, and animals may stand with a hunched posture or lie in unusual positions. Depression progresses from mild dullness to profound lethargy. Animals may seek shade or shelter even in mild weather. Vocalization decreases, and animals become unresponsive to stimuli that would normally elicit reaction. In group exposure situations, multiple animals showing similar behavioral changes simultaneously provides an important clue to toxic exposure.

Physical signs of oxalate nephropathy include dehydration despite access to water, reflecting kidney dysfunction and reduced drinking. Mucous membranes may appear pale or muddy rather than healthy pink. Heart rate is often elevated, and in hypocalcemic animals, heart sounds may be weak or irregular. Body temperature may be normal, low, or elevated depending on the stage and complications. Muscle tremors, weakness, and incoordination from hypocalcemia may be evident. Abdominal distension from ileus can develop as gastrointestinal motility decreases. In animals surviving the acute phase, progressive weight loss and poor condition develop as chronic kidney dysfunction persists.

Symptom progression in oxalate nephropathy typically moves from early nonspecific signs through more obvious illness to either recovery with treatment or deterioration to terminal kidney failure. Animals with moderate exposure may show self-limiting illness that resolves over several days with removal from the toxic source and supportive care. Severe exposure leads to progressive weakness, recumbency, and in many cases death within twenty-four to seventy-two hours. Animals that survive the acute crisis may enter a recovery phase or may develop chronic kidney disease with ongoing clinical signs. Serial monitoring of kidney function parameters helps distinguish recovering from deteriorating cases.

Emergency symptoms requiring immediate veterinary intervention include profound weakness or inability to rise, severe muscle tremors or tetanic spasms suggesting dangerous hypocalcemia, complete anorexia lasting more than twenty-four hours, marked decrease in urine output, rapid breathing suggesting metabolic acidosis, multiple animals affected simultaneously, or any animal found recumbent in an area with known toxic plant populations. Given the rapid progression possible with severe oxalate toxicosis, early intervention dramatically improves prognosis, making prompt recognition and response critical.

Diagnosis

Clinical examination for oxalate nephropathy begins with assessment of the environment and history, focusing on access to plants known to contain oxalates and recent management changes such as movement to new pasture. Physical examination evaluates hydration status, cardiovascular function, neuromuscular status for signs of hypocalcemia, and overall condition. Assessment of multiple animals helps distinguish individual illness from group-wide toxic exposure. Urine should be collected if possible for both immediate assessment and laboratory analysis. The presence of characteristic calcium oxalate crystals in urine sediment, when present, provides strong supportive evidence for the diagnosis.

Diagnostic tests for suspected oxalate nephropathy include serum biochemistry to assess kidney function and calcium status. Blood urea nitrogen and creatinine elevations indicate impaired kidney function. Hypocalcemia confirms significant oxalate absorption and systemic effects. Hyperphosphatemia often accompanies kidney dysfunction. Metabolic acidosis may be present. Urinalysis reveals characteristic monohydrate and dihydrate calcium oxalate crystals in the urine sediment, which provide nearly pathognomonic evidence of oxalate toxicosis when present in significant numbers. Specific gravity may be inappropriate for the animal's hydration status, reflecting impaired concentration ability. Protein and blood in urine indicate tubular damage.

Differential diagnosis for oxalate nephropathy includes other causes of acute kidney failure in ruminants such as aminoglycoside toxicity, heavy metal poisoning, or other nephrotoxic plant ingestions. Hypocalcemia from oxalate toxicosis must be distinguished from milk fever in periparturient cattle, grass tetany in grazing cattle, and transport tetany in sheep. Other toxic plants that cause nonspecific illness, neurological signs, or gastrointestinal effects must be considered based on regional flora. Infectious diseases causing depression and inappetence should be ruled out. The combination of hypocalcemia, kidney dysfunction, and characteristic urinary crystals in an animal with access to oxalate plants usually allows confident diagnosis.

Herd-level diagnostics are essential when multiple animals are affected. Pasture survey to identify oxalate-containing plant species present, with assessment of their abundance and the degree to which animals appear to be grazing them, guides management response. Plant samples can be submitted for oxalate content analysis to confirm toxicity potential. Examination and testing of multiple animals, both clinically affected and apparently healthy herdmates, helps assess the extent of exposure. Necropsy of animals that die provides definitive diagnostic information through histopathologic demonstration of characteristic calcium oxalate crystals within renal tubules. Documentation of the outbreak supports future prevention efforts and may be relevant for insurance or legal purposes.

Treatment Options

Emergency and immediate treatment for oxalate nephropathy focuses on removing animals from the toxic plant source and addressing life-threatening hypocalcemia if present. Intravenous calcium administration using calcium borogluconate solution provides rapid correction of dangerously low calcium levels, with careful monitoring for cardiac arrhythmias during infusion. Intravenous fluid therapy supports kidney perfusion and promotes excretion of absorbed oxalates. Oral administration of calcium-containing compounds such as dicalcium phosphate or limestone can help bind remaining oxalates in the gastrointestinal tract before absorption, though efficacy decreases with time since ingestion. Moving affected animals to safe pasture or providing alternative feed eliminates ongoing exposure.

Medical management of oxalate nephropathy beyond initial emergency care involves continued supportive therapy. Ongoing fluid therapy, whether intravenous in severely affected animals or oral in milder cases, supports kidney function during the recovery phase. Additional calcium supplementation may be needed as initial treatment effects wane and absorbed oxalates continue to bind calcium. Correction of acid-base and electrolyte abnormalities improves overall metabolic status. Anti-inflammatory agents may help reduce kidney inflammation, though non-steroidal agents must be used cautiously given existing kidney compromise. Prokinetic agents may help if gastrointestinal stasis is significant. In food-producing animals, all treatments must respect withdrawal time requirements.

Surgical options are generally not applicable to oxalate nephropathy since the damage is to kidney parenchyma rather than a surgically correctable lesion. However, if concurrent conditions requiring surgery are present, decisions must account for the compromised kidney function's effects on anesthesia, drug metabolism, and healing. Rarely, urolithiasis may develop secondary to high urinary calcium oxalate load, potentially requiring surgical intervention for obstruction.

Supportive care measures for animals with oxalate nephropathy include providing a comfortable, low-stress environment with protection from weather extremes and easy access to clean water and palatable feed. Recumbent animals require frequent turning, soft bedding, and assistance rising if possible. Oral electrolyte solutions may be offered to encourage fluid intake. Nutritional support should provide adequate energy without excessive protein that would increase kidney workload. Monitoring body weight and clinical parameters guides adjustment of care. Animals with severe illness may require extended nursing care through the recovery period.

Herd treatment protocols following group exposure to oxalate plants involve moving all exposed animals away from the toxic plants immediately, regardless of whether they show clinical signs. Animals showing any symptoms should receive individual assessment and appropriate treatment. The entire group benefits from provision of alternative feed and clean water, and oral calcium supplementation may be warranted even in asymptomatic animals to help buffer any absorbed oxalates. Enhanced monitoring for several days allows early detection of delayed onset cases. Severely affected pastures should be fenced off or animals relocated entirely until the toxic plants can be managed.

Treatment decision factors in oxalate nephropathy cases include the severity of clinical signs, the number of animals affected, available veterinary and nursing resources, and economic considerations. Individual valuable animals with severe illness may warrant intensive care including prolonged hospitalization. In mass exposure events with many animals showing varying degrees of illness, triage may be necessary to direct resources toward animals with treatable conditions while providing humane euthanasia for those unlikely to survive. Early intervention improves outcomes across the board, emphasizing the importance of rapid response when toxic plant exposure is suspected.

Recovery & Prognosis

Recovery timeline for oxalate nephropathy varies considerably based on the severity of exposure and resulting kidney damage. Animals with mild to moderate exposure who receive prompt treatment often show improvement within forty-eight to seventy-two hours and may return to normal within one to two weeks. More severely affected animals face longer recovery periods extending over weeks to months. Some animals recover clinical health but retain permanent kidney damage that may affect long-term productivity. Animals that develop severe acute kidney failure may not survive despite treatment, or may recover only to face chronic kidney insufficiency requiring ongoing management.

Post-treatment care and monitoring are essential components of recovery from oxalate nephropathy. Serial assessment of kidney function through blood chemistry monitoring helps track recovery and identify animals with persistent dysfunction. Urinalysis should show decreasing crystal numbers and improving concentration ability as kidneys heal. Body condition and weight should be monitored to ensure adequate nutrition and recovery from any weight loss during illness. Animals should be protected from stress and maintained on appropriate feed and clean water. Pasture management should prevent any re-exposure to oxalate-containing plants during the recovery period and beyond.

Prognosis factors for oxalate nephropathy include the quantity of plant material consumed, the delay between consumption and treatment initiation, the degree of hypocalcemia and kidney dysfunction documented, and the individual animal's response to initial treatment. Animals with moderate biochemical abnormalities that improve quickly with treatment have good prognosis. Those with severe kidney failure, particularly if oliguria or anuria develops, face guarded to poor prognosis. Concurrent conditions, advanced age, or other health compromises worsen prognosis. Animals that survive the acute crisis but have persistent kidney dysfunction may have reduced long-term productivity even if immediately life-threatening illness resolves.

Return to production considerations for animals recovering from oxalate nephropathy should account for any residual kidney damage that may affect performance. Repeat kidney function testing several weeks after apparent clinical recovery helps identify animals with subclinical persistent damage. Animals with normal or near-normal kidney function may return to full production roles. Those with documented chronic kidney disease may be suitable for maintenance in the herd with reduced production expectations, or culling may be more practical depending on their value and the operation's capacity to manage animals with special needs. Breeding decisions should consider whether affected animals should be retained in the gene pool, though oxalate nephropathy itself is not hereditary.

Prevention

Vaccination protocols are not applicable to oxalate nephropathy prevention since this is a toxic condition rather than an infectious disease. Prevention efforts must focus on eliminating or minimizing exposure to oxalate-containing plants through pasture management and livestock handling practices. General herd health programs should maintain overall animal health and appropriate nutrition, which supports resilience to various stressors including potential toxin exposures.

Biosecurity measures in the traditional sense do not apply to plant toxicoses, but management of feed sources can be considered analogous. Purchased hay or feed should be inspected for contamination with oxalate-containing weeds. Grain screenings or mill byproducts should be evaluated for weed seed contamination. Garden waste fed to livestock should not include rhubarb leaves or other high-oxalate materials. Quality control of incoming feed materials prevents inadvertent exposure through contaminated feedstuffs.

Nutritional prevention of oxalate nephropathy centers on ensuring adequate calcium nutrition and preventing situations where animals might consume toxic plants due to hunger. Diets adequate in calcium provide buffering capacity against modest oxalate absorption. Animals maintained on nutritious diets with adequate forage are less likely to consume toxic plants that they would normally avoid. Avoiding nutritional stress, particularly during periods when toxic plants are most dangerous, reduces risk. Supplemental feed during drought or other periods of reduced forage availability keeps animals from becoming hungry enough to consume plants they would otherwise reject.

Management practices for preventing oxalate nephropathy focus on pasture management and livestock handling. Learning to identify oxalate-containing plants common to the region enables targeted management. Dense stands of toxic plants should be fenced off, treated with herbicides, or otherwise removed from areas where livestock graze. When moving animals to new pastures, especially unfamiliar range, scouting for toxic plants before introducing stock prevents tragic losses. Animals should be fed before transport and turnout onto new pastures so they are not hungry enough to consume unfamiliar and potentially toxic plants immediately upon arrival. Gradual introduction may allow some rumen flora adaptation to moderate oxalate levels.

Quarantine and testing protocols for plant toxicoses differ from infectious disease applications. Before livestock are introduced to new grazing areas, pastures should be surveyed for toxic plants and appropriate management implemented. Animals being moved from areas without toxic plants to areas where they occur should be considered at risk and managed accordingly. Monitoring newly introduced animals closely for several days allows early detection of any toxic plant consumption. Maintaining awareness of which pastures have toxic plant issues supports long-term prevention through appropriate livestock placement and grazing rotation.

Living With & Managing Oxalate Nephropathy

Daily management and monitoring to prevent oxalate nephropathy requires ongoing awareness of toxic plant locations and animal behavior. Producers should regularly assess pastures for toxic plant populations, noting any changes in abundance or distribution over time and seasons. Observing animal grazing behavior may reveal whether livestock are avoiding certain areas or plants, providing indication of toxic species presence. Daily observation of animal health status allows early detection of any illness that might suggest toxic plant consumption. During high-risk periods such as drought or early spring when toxic plants may be especially abundant or palatable, increased vigilance is warranted.

Housing and environmental management to prevent oxalate nephropathy focuses primarily on pasture management for grazing operations. Maintaining healthy pastures with adequate desirable forage reduces the likelihood that animals will consume toxic plants. Rotational grazing systems that prevent overgrazing help maintain forage availability. Areas with heavy toxic plant growth should be excluded from grazing through fencing or should be managed to reduce toxic plant populations before livestock access. In confined operations, ensuring that hay, silage, and other harvested forages are free from oxalate-containing weeds prevents inadvertent exposure. Clean water sources should be maintained, as contamination with decomposing plant material could theoretically contribute oxalate exposure.

Herd health programs should incorporate toxic plant awareness as a component of overall health management. Working with extension services, veterinarians, or range management specialists to identify local toxic plants and develop management strategies reduces risk. Staff training on toxic plant identification and recognition of toxicosis symptoms enables rapid response when problems occur. Health programs should include protocols for response to suspected plant poisoning, including contact information for veterinary assistance and steps for immediate field response. Regular review and updating of these protocols maintains readiness.

Record keeping and monitoring systems should document toxic plant locations on the operation, any historical poisoning events, and pasture use patterns. Mapping toxic plant distributions allows targeted management and informed decisions about livestock placement. Records of any illness events, including necropsy findings when available, contribute to understanding of local risks. Production records may reveal subtle impacts of subclinical toxin exposure if correlated with pasture use. Weather and environmental records help anticipate conditions that might increase toxic plant risk.

Economic considerations for managing oxalate nephropathy risk include the costs of pasture management interventions such as herbicide application or fencing compared to potential losses from poisoning events. In areas with significant toxic plant populations, investment in prevention is typically well justified by avoidance of livestock losses. The cost of emergency veterinary intervention for poisoned animals, combined with the often-guarded prognosis and production losses in survivors, favors proactive management. Insurance may cover some losses but prevention remains economically preferable. When evaluating new grazing leases or pasture purchases, toxic plant assessment should be part of due diligence.

Breeds at Risk for Oxalate Nephropathy

High-risk breeds and species for oxalate nephropathy are not defined by breed genetics but rather by management circumstances that determine exposure to toxic plants. Sheep are often considered the most susceptible species to acute oxalate poisoning, with numerous documented mass mortality events following exposure to halogeton and similar plants. Cattle are also highly susceptible and represent significant economic losses when exposed. Goats, while somewhat more selective grazers, are fully susceptible when they do consume oxalate plants. Horses and pigs may be affected when exposed to oxalate sources though they less commonly encounter toxic plants in typical management situations. All grazing livestock should be considered at risk when oxalate plants are present.

Production type considerations influence oxalate nephropathy risk primarily through determining which animals encounter toxic plants. Range cattle and sheep in extensive Western United States operations face the highest risk of encountering halogeton and other rangeland toxic plants. Intensively managed dairy or feedlot cattle rarely encounter toxic plants unless contaminated feeds are provided. Pasture-raised livestock of all types may be at risk depending on regional toxic plant distribution. Hobby farms and small acreages may unknowingly harbor toxic plants that more experienced producers would recognize and manage. Show and pleasure animals given access to diverse forages or garden waste face potential exposure from materials not normally fed to livestock.

Genetic selection and testing for oxalate nephropathy susceptibility is not practiced since the condition results from toxic exposure rather than genetic defect. No breeds have demonstrated resistance or enhanced susceptibility to oxalate toxicity under equivalent exposure conditions. However, some variation in grazing behavior between breeds and individuals may affect the likelihood of consuming toxic plants when they are present alongside palatable forages. Selection should focus on appropriate livestock placement and management rather than seeking genetic solutions. Education of producers about toxic plant risks and management provides greater protection than any theoretical genetic improvement.

Related Conditions

Commonly co-occurring conditions with oxalate nephropathy relate primarily to the hypocalcemia that accompanies significant oxalate absorption. Acute hypocalcemia can cause neuromuscular dysfunction ranging from mild tremors to tetanic seizures, which may be the presenting sign before kidney failure becomes apparent. Hypocalcemia also affects cardiac function and smooth muscle tone throughout the body. Secondary rumen stasis and bloat may develop from hypocalcemia's effects on gastrointestinal motility. Animals surviving acute oxalate toxicosis may develop chronic kidney disease affecting long-term health and productivity. In some cases, oxalate kidney stones may form, potentially causing urinary obstruction as a later complication.

Conditions with similar symptoms to oxalate nephropathy include other causes of hypocalcemia such as milk fever in periparturient dairy cattle, grass tetany from magnesium deficiency, and transport tetany in sheep. Other nephrotoxic plant poisonings may cause similar kidney failure signs without the characteristic hypocalcemia. Infectious diseases causing nonspecific depression and inappetence must be considered. Other plant toxicoses affecting the nervous system, gastrointestinal tract, or multiple organ systems are geographic and seasonally variable differential diagnoses. The combination of hypocalcemia, kidney dysfunction, and urinary oxalate crystals, along with history of access to oxalate plants, usually allows differentiation from these other conditions.

Complications and sequelae of oxalate nephropathy include death from acute kidney failure or profound hypocalcemia in severe cases. Animals surviving acute illness may develop chronic kidney disease with reduced kidney function persisting indefinitely. Chronic kidney disease leads to secondary complications including anemia, bone mineral abnormalities, and impaired growth in young animals. Rare cases may develop oxalate urolithiasis with potential for urinary obstruction. Production impacts in survivors may include reduced milk yield, impaired weight gain, and decreased reproductive efficiency. The extent of long-term complications depends largely on the severity of initial exposure and the degree of permanent kidney damage sustained.