Plains Garter Snakes are opportunistic carnivores with remarkably diverse natural diets reflecting their generalist foraging strategies in varied prairie habitats. Wild individuals consume earthworms, leeches, slugs, grasshoppers, crickets, other insects, spiders, frogs, toads, tadpoles, salamanders, small fish, and occasionally very small mammals including young mice. This dietary flexibility provides survival advantages in variable environments but creates feeding challenges in captivity compared to species with simpler, rodent-focused diets requiring standardized feeding protocols.
In captivity, dietary options include rodents, fish, earthworms, or combinations thereof. The ideal scenario involves converting snakes to appropriately-sized frozen-thawed mice, as rodents provide complete, balanced nutrition, are readily available commercially, and simplify husbandry compared to other food sources. Many captive-bred Plains Garter Snakes raised on rodents from birth accept pinkie and fuzzy mice readily. However, wild-caught specimens and some captive-bred individuals show variable acceptance, with some refusing rodents persistently despite extended attempts. These individuals may require alternative food sources or scenting techniques.
Earthworm-based diets represent a natural feeding option many Plains Garter Snakes accept enthusiastically. High-quality earthworms purchased from bait shops or cultured specifically for reptile feeding provide reasonable nutrition, though they are less calorically dense than rodents requiring more frequent feeding. Ensure earthworms are sourced from pesticide-free environments. Some keepers successfully maintain garter snakes on earthworm-based diets supplemented with occasional rodents and fish, though this approach requires more effort than standard rodent feeding. Earthworm-exclusive diets may require supplementation to prevent nutritional deficiencies over time.
Fish-based diets are readily accepted by most Plains Garter Snakes but present nutritional challenges. Small feeder fish including minnows, guppies, and small goldfish may be offered, though fish-exclusive diets can lead to thiamine deficiency from thiaminase enzymes in certain fish species. If feeding fish, use thiaminase-free species like silversides, or supplement with vitamin B1 to prevent deficiencies. Frozen silversides from reptile suppliers are convenient, nutritionally appropriate options. Avoid exclusive reliance on goldfish or rosy red minnows due to thiaminase content. Fish feeding also creates water quality issues if snakes are fed in enclosures rather than separate feeding containers.
Feeding schedules vary by prey type, snake size, and individual metabolism. Hatchlings fed appropriately-sized prey (pinkie mice, earthworm pieces, or small fish) require feeding every 3-5 days supporting rapid growth. Juveniles transition to every 5-7 days as prey size increases. Adults maintain optimal body condition on weekly or bi-weekly feedings depending on prey size and type. Earthworm-based diets may require more frequent feeding than rodent-based diets due to lower caloric density. Monitor body condition carefully, adjusting frequency as needed—visible spine indicates underfeeding while excessive thickness suggests overfeeding.
Scenting techniques help convert reluctant feeders to rodents. Common methods include rubbing pinkie mice with earthworms, fish, or frog skin to transfer attractive scents, or "braining" rodents (exposing brain matter) to release appealing odors. Some keepers successfully transition snakes from earthworms to worm-scented pinkies to unscented rodents gradually over weeks or months. Patience and persistence often succeed eventually, though some individuals never fully convert requiring lifetime alternative diets or scenting protocols.
Supplementation requirements depend on diet type. Snakes consuming whole rodents receive complete nutrition without supplementation. Those on earthworm-based diets benefit from occasional dusting with reptile vitamins and calcium. Fish-based diets may require vitamin B1 (thiamine) supplementation preventing deficiencies from thiaminase. Consult with reptile veterinarians about appropriate supplementation protocols for non-rodent diets. The dietary complexity of garter snakes makes them slightly more challenging than species with straightforward frozen-thawed rodent protocols, requiring keepers to be flexible, patient, and willing to accommodate individual preferences while ensuring complete nutrition.